Are you looking for a high-quality, comfortable, durable dog bed?
If so, I will be comparing the Casper Dog Bed vs Big Barker today.
We’ll look at the covers, foams, bolsters, durability, and more to determine which is better for your furry friend.
And if you want a quick answer about which bed is the best overall, after careful consideration, I’ve determined that the Big Barker offers comfortable US-made beds for large breeds or dogs with joint pain.
However, for more budget-friendly options, Casper offers a range of beds that are much more affordable.
Let’s dive into the details and compare these two beds side-by-side.
- High-quality Orthopedic Foam
- Clinically Proven for Less Pain
- Calibrated for Big Dogs
Key Differences: Casper Dog bed vs Big Barker
| Feature | Casper Dog Bed | Big Barker Dog Bed |
| Size | Small, Medium, and Large | Large, X-Large, and Giant |
| Style | Bolster | Headrest, Sleek, and Sofa. |
| Weight | Small: 5 lbs, Medium: 8 lbs, Large: 10 lbs | Large: 15 lbs, X-Large: 19 lbs, Giant: 28 lbs |
| Cover Materials | Nylon | Microfiber |
| Support Material | Memory Foam | Orthopedic Foam |
| Cleaning | Removable Cover, Machine-washable | Removable Cover, Machine Washable |
| Durability | Chew Resistant | Tear Resistant but not Chew Proof |
| Price | $ | $$ |
| Colors | 4 colors | 4 colors |
| Warranty | 1-year Limited Warranty | 10-year Won’t Flatten Warranty |
| Made in | USA | USA |
| Features | Pressure-relieving memory foam and durable support foam, supportive foam bolsters, and impenetrable and slobber-resistant cover | Calibrated for big dogs, clinically proven for less pain and more mobility after use, and high-quality orthopedic foam |
Size:
I will start by comparing the easy stuff, such as the sizes of both beds, and then move on to the more complex stuff.
Casper offers three sizes for their beds: small, medium, and large.
The dimensions of the dog bed are as follows: Small (25″ x 19″ x 6″), Medium (33″ x 25″ x 6″), and Large (45″ x 35″ x 7″).
The Small bed can accommodate dogs up to 30 lbs, Medium sizes up to 60 lbs, and Large up to 90 lbs.
On the other hand, Big Barker also provides three sizes for their beds: Large, X-Large, and Giant.
The dimensions of the dog bed are as follows: Large (48″ x 30″ x 7″), X-Large (52″ x 36″ x 7″), and Giant (60″ x 48″ x 7″).
Although Big Barker doesn’t mention how much weight each bed can accommodate, they have mentioned on their website that their Large beds can accommodate breeds like Golden Retriever, X-Large beds are suitable for German Shepherds, and Giant beds are perfect for Great Danes.
In terms of the size of the bed, both offer three sizes options, but Big Barker has larger sizes and can accommodate even the most giant dogs.
Style:
I believe style is a huge part of choosing the right bed for your dog.
Because some dogs like to curl up while other likes to sleep in a more stretched position.
Casper comes in one style, while Big Barker offers three different styles.
Casper offers a bolstered design, which is excellent for dogs who love to curl up.
While Big Barker provides three styles: Headrest (most popular from big barker), Sleek, and Sofa.
The Headrest Big Barker comes with one side raised for head and neck support, the sleek design is an entirely flat bed for dogs that like to stretch, and the Sofa style is designed with bolters to provide a secure place for your buddy and curl up.
So if the style is essential to you, Big Barker will have more options for you to choose from.
Weight:
The next thing I want to compare is the weight of the beds.
Casper dog beds are lighter than Big Barker beds, with the Small bed weighing 5 lbs, the Medium bed 8 lbs, and the Large bed 10 lbs.
Big Barker, on the other hand, weighs more than Casper beds, with the Large bed weighing 15 lbs, X-Large 19 lbs, and Giant 28 lbs.
If you’re looking for a lightweight bed, Casper is the way to go.
Materials:
So now let’s talk about the materials used in both beds.
Casper’s bed cover is made of nylon fabric, and the bed is filled with memory foam.
Big Barker beds have microfiber covers and are filled with orthopedic foam.
Both beds are made in the USA and come in 4 different colors.
And both beds are easy to clean also.
So both are similar in terms of materials used.
Durability:
Next, let’s talk about the durability of both beds.
In terms of durability, both have tear-resistant covers that can withstand some digging and nesting but won’t last for determined chewers.
Both beds have done a good job hiding the zippers so dogs won’t chew through.
Therefore, I would say both have an equal level of durability.
Cleaning:
I will now compare both beds in washability and ease of cleanliness.
Because cleaning your dog’s bed is essential as it helps keep it looking and smelling nice.
Casper has removable covers that you can wash easily in cold water on a gentle cycle. After washing, tumble dry on low heat. An enzyme-based spot cleaner should do the trick if tough stains are present.
Big Barker’s covers are also machine washable and can be removed and washed in a front-loading machine.
So when it comes to cleaning, both beds are machine washable and easy to clean.
Warranty:
When buying a dog bed or any other product, one must consider the warranty because it is essential to know that the product will be replaced if damaged.
The Casper dog bed comes with a 1 Year Limited Dog Bed Warranty, which only applies to specific defects, as stated on their website.
On the other hand, Big Barker stands behind their product with a 10-year warranty that ensures the bed won’t flatten. This warranty guarantees that your dog’s bed will maintain at least 90% of its shape, and if it does not, Big Barker will replace the foam at no cost to you.
However, it’s important to note that this warranty does not cover damage to the bed covers or any destruction caused by chewing.
Price:
And finally, let’s compare the prices of both beds.
The Casper dog beds are more affordable than the big barkers but offer the same comfort and durability.
Customer Reviews:
But before moving to the conclusion, I will give you an overview of what I analyzed from thousands of customer reviews from both beds.
Generally, the Big Barker has more reviews than the Casper dog bed.
Casper Dog Bed:
Customers liked the quality of the bed, saying it was well-made and comfortable for their dogs.
Customers also mentioned that the bed is stylish and looks great.
However, some customers reported that the bed was not water-repellent, but overall they were satisfied with their purchase.
Big Barker Dog Bed:
Customers noted this bed offered excellent support and comfort for their large dogs, especially those with joint or mobility issues.
They also noted that the microfiber covering was easy to clean and that the therapeutic bedding held its shape, providing a soft surface for their pups to lay on.
Some customers were unhappy with the price, but many were impressed with the 10-year warranty.
Casper Dog Bed vs Big Barker: The Winner
Overall, the Big Barker dog bed is an excellent choice for dogs with joint pain or mobility issues and big dogs in general.
It provides excellent support and comfort while a 10-year won’t flatten warranty makes it even more appealing to buyers who want peace of mind that their purchase will last them many years.
On the other hand, if you’re looking for an affordable option without compromising quality, then Casper’s bolster dog beds are ideal for medium to small dogs.
Both offer removable covers so you can keep your dog’s bed clean and comfortable all year round!
If you don’t like either, don’t forget to check out our other dog bed comparisons and roundup reviews on the best dog beds.
Related Articles:
